• About
  • Archive
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Dana Blankenhorn
  • Home
  • About Dana
  • Posts
  • Contact Dana
  • Archive
  • A-clue.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Dana
  • Posts
  • Contact Dana
  • Archive
  • A-clue.com
No Result
View All Result
Dana Blankenhorn
No Result
View All Result
Home Film

The Jazz Singer

by Dana Blankenhorn
October 18, 2007
in Film, history, Personal, Television
0
0
SHARES
3
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

And now for something completely different…

The_jazz_singer_
I’m no film reviewer, but I just felt a need to tell you about an amazing film I saw on TV the other day.

The Jazz Singer.

Stop laughing a moment. This is one of those films we all assume we know, because of what we’ve been told about it, and because it’s something that is supposed to be in our collective conscious. As the first mass market talking picture, it’s one of the most important films of all time, and when we think about it all that’s what we usually think about.

The Jazz Singer opened 80 years ago this month. It is regularly derided by critics as a minor piece, and in some ways it is. All the spoken parts are done as a silent, complete with speech cards, so there’s this shock when Jolson suddenly starts singing, an excitement you can still feel on behalf of your grandparents and great-grandparents.

But, seeing the whole thing, there is so much more. The actors are behaving as in a talkie, without the heavy pancake and darkened lips of so many silents. Even in the sections which are silent, it’s distinctively different. All the acting is naturalistic, not the measured pantomime we associate with the period.

Jolson_in_and_out_of_blackface
Another important point, seldom made, is that this may be the American
film which showed the most respect for Jewish culture, specifically
Eastern European Jewish culture, in the 20th century. No film of the
30s, 40s, or even the 50s showed the temple, or a piece of the Yom
Kippur service, or treated the cantor of the temple as a hero. This
film does.

Slight spoiler. While the film is best known, if at all, for Jolson’s
performance of "Mammy" at the end, in full blackface, this is actually
a father-son story, a story about assimilation, a story of America and
what’s lost when we enter into it. Jolson is the cantor’s son, with the
cantor’s voice, and wants nothing so much as to become a famous
American singer. Which he does. But respect must be paid. You can have
America, but if you don’t keep the Old Country close you will lose your
soul. It’s a very modern story in that respect.

One more point about the blackface. It’s never explained, never
defended. It is so much of that era’s fabric the audience doesn’t feel
a need for that. We see Jolson put on the make-up, we see him appear to
his mother in it, we see that she doesn’t recognize him at first, and
we see him singing in it. Supposedly the idea was that a white actor in
blackface would feel "more free," better able to let loose and express
himself, hidden behind the mask. Supposedly the idea was that if you
were to sing black, you had to look and act it. Which you don’t.

I can certainly appreciate how many of my neighbors feel about this.
They feel insulted, and should. But this should not detract as much as
it seems to from the achievement of the film. If Jolson had put on
clown makeup and done Pagliacci it would have been the same thing. It
makes this a mature film, yes something of a period piece.

But talkies could have had a much worse start. Which was a lesson to me, and I hope will be a lesson to you.

Tags: Al Jolsonanti-semitismblackfacejudaismracismTCMThe Jazz SingerTurner Classic Movies
Previous Post

Hydrogen and Drought

Next Post

This Week’s Clue: The Three Party System

Dana Blankenhorn

Dana Blankenhorn

Dana Blankenhorn began his career as a financial journalist in 1978, began covering technology in 1982, and the Internet in 1985. He started one of the first Internet daily newsletters, the Interactive Age Daily, in 1994. He recently retired from InvestorPlace and lives in Atlanta, GA, preparing for his next great adventure. He's a graduate of Rice University (1977) and Northwestern's Medill School of Journalism (MSJ 1978). He's a native of Massapequa, NY.

Next Post
This Week’s Clue: The Three Party System

This Week's Clue: The Three Party System

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Post

The E-Transport Revolution Rolls On

Change the Subject, Atlanta

May 14, 2025
The Coming Labor War

The Insanity of Wealth

May 7, 2025
Tachtig Jaar Van Vrede en Vrijheid

Tachtig Jaar Van Vrede en Vrijheid

May 5, 2025
Make America Dutch Again

Make America Dutch Again

April 30, 2025
Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!


Archives

Categories

Recent Comments

  • Dana Blankenhorn on The Death of Video
  • danablank on The Problem of the Moment (Is Not the Problem of the Moment)
  • cipit88 on The Problem of the Moment (Is Not the Problem of the Moment)
  • danablank on What I Learned on my European Vacation
  • danablank on Boomer Roomers

I'm Dana Blankenhorn. I have covered the Internet as a reporter since 1983. I've been a professional business reporter since 1978, and a writer all my life.

  • Italian Trulli

Browse by Category

Newsletter


Powered by FeedBlitz
  • About
  • Archive
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

© 2023 Dana Blankenhorn - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Dana
  • Posts
  • Contact Dana
  • Archive
  • A-clue.com

© 2023 Dana Blankenhorn - All Rights Reserved