• About
  • Archive
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact
Dana Blankenhorn
  • Home
  • About Dana
  • Posts
  • Contact Dana
  • Archive
  • A-clue.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Dana
  • Posts
  • Contact Dana
  • Archive
  • A-clue.com
No Result
View All Result
Dana Blankenhorn
No Result
View All Result
Home Current Affairs

Solving The Pundit Problem

by Dana Blankenhorn
January 10, 2007
in Current Affairs, history, Internet, journalism, Personal, political philosophy, politics, Weblogs
2
0
SHARES
2
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Hl_mencken
Analysts are hired by media companies to explain Washington to the people "back home." They live in Washington, and in time nearly all "go native."

The most important pundits work for the dominant media. As I’ve noted before, each generation’s thesis also brings with it a new dominant medium. Under the Progressive Thesis, from 1896-1932, these were newspapermen like H.L. Mencken (right).

Under the FDR Thesis of Unity from 1932-68, many came to work in the electronic media, first on radio and later on TV. Conservatives complained loudly during this period that these people were "unelected," and "unreachable." Since they had "gone native" and expressed the dominant thesis of their time, most were liberal in outlook — the Republicans tended to express the Eisenhower AntiThesis. Movement conservatism was not heard.

David_broder_1
Since 1968 we have developed a new set of media, TV and cable. And we have developed a new way to hire pundits. They are no longer taken from the ranks of working journalists. They are hired by think tanks, which are backed by corporations and multi-millionaires. After 40 years they are uniformly conservative. They either follow the Nixon Thesis of Conflict that has dominated our politics since 1968, or the Clinton AntiThesis, a "third way" that leans against that thesis and only seeks to moderate it, never to challenge it (because a challenge, they assume, would fail).

Bloggers are absolutely shocked, shocked at the "work" of these hacks. They are right to be angry. High Broderism (that’s David Broder above) has failed us utterly. It needs to be replaced, its practitioners retired.

Duncan_black
But we also need to understand the times we are in. This is a period
of Crisis. The old Thesis has crumbled. Everyone knows this. The real
problems of the nation and the world are not being addressed. This was
true in 1967, it was true in 1931, it was true in 1895 and it was true
in 1859. It’s the brain-dead idiocy of the Pundits that is proof we are
entering a new era. (To the left, un-pundit Duncan Black of Atrios.)

These bloggers also need to understand that people are now turning to
them, to become the new elite, a meritocracy based on the quality of
their writing and the quality of their thought. The Internet is
intensely democratic. Unlike TV, even cable, you have the power here,
by what you read, what you link to, and what you recommend, to steer
the debate. That’s something of what Time Magazine was getting at when
they named you its Person of the Year, but it got lost in the muddle over YouTube postings and MySpace pages.

Instead of complaining, bloggers need to get back to work, and on the
whole most are doing that. And you need to get back to work — reading,
thinking, linking, recommending, writing. This is the biggest change of
the next Political Thesis, the Internet or Open Source Thesis I have
been talking about here for most of the last year.

Pundits don’t have to live in Washington. Pundits don’t have to work
for Big Media. Pundits are whoever you choose them to be. I can be one,
and so can you.

Tags: AtriosBushDavid BroderHigh BroderismMenckenNixon Political ThesisNixon Thesis of ConflictNixonismpunditrypundits
Previous Post

Jobs-san

Next Post

The Apple MacGuffin

Dana Blankenhorn

Dana Blankenhorn

Dana Blankenhorn began his career as a financial journalist in 1978, began covering technology in 1982, and the Internet in 1985. He started one of the first Internet daily newsletters, the Interactive Age Daily, in 1994. He recently retired from InvestorPlace and lives in Atlanta, GA, preparing for his next great adventure. He's a graduate of Rice University (1977) and Northwestern's Medill School of Journalism (MSJ 1978). He's a native of Massapequa, NY.

Next Post
The Apple MacGuffin

The Apple MacGuffin

Comments 2

  1. Avedon says:
    18 years ago

    That’s something of what Time Magazine was getting at when they named you its Person of the Year, but it got lost in the muddle over YouTube postings and MySpace pages.
    I think that was the point – they couldn’t very well ignore the Internet altogether, so they pretended it was about “everyone” rather than the very specific fact that the liberal blogosphere was being chosen over them as the place to find out what’s going on.

    Reply
  2. Avedon says:
    18 years ago

    That’s something of what Time Magazine was getting at when they named you its Person of the Year, but it got lost in the muddle over YouTube postings and MySpace pages.
    I think that was the point – they couldn’t very well ignore the Internet altogether, so they pretended it was about “everyone” rather than the very specific fact that the liberal blogosphere was being chosen over them as the place to find out what’s going on.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Post

Game Changer

Game Changer

May 19, 2025
My AirBnB Trip

My AirBnB Trip

May 18, 2025
The Ride Back Home

The Ride Back Home

May 17, 2025
Bicycle Diplomacy Changing the World

Bicycle Diplomacy Changing the World

May 16, 2025
Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!


Archives

Categories

Recent Comments

  • Dana Blankenhorn on The Death of Video
  • danablank on The Problem of the Moment (Is Not the Problem of the Moment)
  • cipit88 on The Problem of the Moment (Is Not the Problem of the Moment)
  • danablank on What I Learned on my European Vacation
  • danablank on Boomer Roomers

I'm Dana Blankenhorn. I have covered the Internet as a reporter since 1983. I've been a professional business reporter since 1978, and a writer all my life.

  • Italian Trulli

Browse by Category

Newsletter


Powered by FeedBlitz
  • About
  • Archive
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

© 2023 Dana Blankenhorn - All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Dana
  • Posts
  • Contact Dana
  • Archive
  • A-clue.com

© 2023 Dana Blankenhorn - All Rights Reserved