Slaves to Munich

Why do we have crises every generation?

Because of assumptions that span generations.

The most famous such problem is slavery. It lay, in Lincoln's words, like a coiled snake under the table during the deliberations of the Constitution.

By the time of the Civil War, that snake had lain underneath our table for 72 years, protected and nurtured by the Constitution. This is why, in his Gettysburg Address, Lincoln dated the founding of America not from that document, but from the Declaration of Independence 13 years earlier, “four score and seven” (87) years ago.

He did this for a reason. He did it to overturn the powerful assumptions of his time. Old assumptions have enormous power over the future, even after they have become worthless.

The same was true for the problems of the 1890s which brought us Populism and Progressivism. Their root causes were to be found in Jacksonian Democracy, the lack of a central bank and the reliance on tariffs to fund the government. This meant there was nothing but gold on which to base our currency, and nothing but tariff revenue to fund operations. President Grover Cleveland was forced to borrow gold from J.P. Morgan to keep the government going following the Panic of 1893.

The causes of the 1960s crisis were of a similar age. From Cleveland's time, as Hofstadter wrote in books like The Age of Reform, America had stood for constant social, political, and economic change, always more tolerant, always more liberal, always more egalitarian. The Greatest Generation saw what this was doing to their children, freedom interpreted as license, and they said, as one, "enough."

Our crisis also has a cause, in the form of a generations-old assumption. People like Matthew Yglesias say they are shocked at government attempts to excuse and rationalize our Iraq disaster.

But if he listened to the Secretary of Defense last week, he would have heard it loud, clear, and proud.

Munich.

But Munich is not the only lesson.

No lesson, and no assumption, holds forever, immutable, never subject to question.

American foreign policy has become enslaved to Munich. Just as our fathers were enslaved to the Progressive Myth, and their grandfathers were enslaved to Jacksonian Democracy, just as those mens' fathers were enslaved to the assumption of slavery written in the Constitution, so we are now slaves to the example of Munich.

Our discussion of foreign policy will not move forward until we face this slavery and deal with it, once and for all. Munich is not always the only lesson. Just a generation before Munich, it was over-reliance on the Balance of Power that plunged Europe  into World War. Chamberlain's mistake at Munich was relying on this assumption as an immutable lesson.

There are no immutable lessons, no strategies that work for all time, in all situations. Life is a continual process of growth and adjustment. Wisdom comes from learning that you don't know everything, that your assumptions are open to challenge. You only learn when you change your mind.

It is time we changed our minds about Munich, not in terms of its time but in terms of our time.

No one has the power to destroy America except Americans. Because we are enslaved to the example of Chamberlain at Munich we are doing a very fine job of that.

We have destroyed our nation's reputation. We have destroyed our national budget. We have wrecked our own Army. We are trying to destroy our Constitution.  

All in the name of an historical example that is dead, that is useless to us.

The great lesson of the 20th century remains true today, in the 21st. Anyone can be the Nazi, and anyone can be the Jew. There is nothing about being American which makes you immune from the abuse of others.  There is nothing about being Jewish that makes you perpetually the only victim.

If we fail to bury Munich, then Munich will bury us.